Black Diamond Steakhouse: Premier Steak & Cocktail Dining in Circleville, OH

This place is amazing, the atmosphere great and the bartender Nicole is outstanding. First time ever having deep fried green beans omg to die for. The Prime Rib is on point had it mid rare. The organic brown rice pilaf perfect. if you haven’t tried this Circleville Gem you need to asap!! I should have taken the picture of the fried green beans before I started to dig in it but couldn’t help myself.

I recently dined at Black Diamond, and I must say, it did not disappoint! The atmosphere was inviting, setting the perfect backdrop for a family dinner. I ordered the burger, and it was absolutely fantastic—juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. What truly impressed me was how well the whole family’s dinner went. Each dish we tried was delicious, and the appetizers were particularly on point. They were bursting with flavor and a perfect way to start our meal. If you're looking for a place that offers great food and a welcoming environment, I highly recommend Black Diamond. I can’t wait to go back and try more from their menu!

Our dinner was wonderful! Highly recommend! Congrats Circleville & Black Diamond! We also enjoy the Black Diamond Tavern in Shawnee!

Black Diamond Steakhouse served the finest steak I have ever had. Our waitress was so friendly and made sure everything was perfect. If you're not familiar with Black Diamond look them up. Their tavern in Shawnee Ohio is a great place to spend an evening. They now have several locations throughout southern Ohio. My next stop will be their recently opened Brewery in Marietta. I'll certainly be stopping back at the steakhouse soon.

Unbelievable dining experience at Black Diamond Steak House! From start to finish, everything was perfection. The filet was cooked absolutely flawlessly — tender, juicy, and bursting with flavor. It practically melted in my mouth. The sautéed butter button mushrooms were the perfect complement — rich, savory, and downright addictive. The signature cocktails were incredible too — beautifully crafted, perfectly balanced, and honestly some of the best we’ve had anywhere. You can tell the bartenders really know their stuff. And then there’s the bourbon molasses pecan pie… WOW. It’s one of those desserts you keep thinking about long after you’ve left. Sweet, nutty, warm, and just the right touch of bourbon — truly the perfect ending to an unforgettable meal. The atmosphere was sophisticated and welcoming, and the staff couldn’t have been nicer. Everyone was friendly, attentive, and made the whole experience feel special. Black Diamond Steak House is hands-down one of the best restaurants around. Between the food, drinks, and service, it’s five stars all the way. We can’t wait to go back!

First time at the new steakhouse and it did not disappoint. The atmosphere and the staff are so nice. Although I am not a bourbon drinker, Black Diamond Bourbon is an exceptionally smooth liquor. However, the mouthwatering Prime Rib was the real star for me. (Wish I had taken a picture). It was perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. And the prices are very reasonable for such high quality. Will definitely be enjoying more meals here.